Enzyme Fragment Complementation Assay (EFCA)
Drug discovery is an exceedingly convoluted and intricate process that involves various arduous steps. These steps include the identification and validation of novel drug targets, the screening of numerous potential drug candidates, and the optimization of lead compounds using a repetitive cycle of design, synthesis, and testing. One of the most pivotal phases in this process is the development of trustworthy and delicate assays for quantifying the activity of enzymes, receptors, and other biomolecules that are targeted by prospective drugs.
In recent years, one of the most auspicious breakthroughs in measuring protein activity has been the advent of Enzyme Fragment Complementation Assay (EFCA) technology. This innovative technology was pioneered by DiscoverX Corporation and has now been extensively adopted by researchers in the pharmaceutical and biotechnology industries. In this article, we aim to provide a comprehensive overview of the EFCA technology, its pros, and cons, as well as its diverse applications in the realm of drug discovery.
The Enzyme Fragment Complementation Assay (EFCA) serves as a go-to methodology for evaluating protein-protein interactions, specifically in the context of measuring enzymes, receptors, and other proteins of interest. The core of EFCA rests on the notion of complementation, whereby two components of a given enzyme or receptor are expressed separately, both within cells or in vitro, only to be reintroduced through the binding of a ligand or the formation of protein-protein interaction.
Once this reunion of the two components takes place, the reunited complex reconstitutes the active enzyme or receptor, thus enabling the quantification of its activity through the use of an array of readouts, ranging from luminescence, and fluorescence, to colorimetry. The beauty of the EFCA technology lies in its versatility and applicability, as it has been adapted to serve a range of applications, including high-throughput screening (HTS) of large compound libraries, profiling of drug selectivity and potency, and identification of novel drug targets and pathways.
The EFCA technology is an intricate mechanism that involves the application of two non-functional fragments of a reporter enzyme or receptor, which are separately expressed in cells or in vitro. The fragments have unique roles, with one referred to as the "donor" fragment, and the other referred to as the "acceptor" fragment. Typically, the "donor" fragment is fused to the N-terminal end of the protein of interest, while the "acceptor" fragment is fused to the C-terminal end, as if they are two separate entities that need to work together to achieve a common goal.
The process of the EFCA technology relies on the ligand or interacting protein that binds to the protein of interest, which ultimately leads to the close proximity of the "donor" and "acceptor" fragments, thus facilitating the reconstitution of the active enzyme or receptor. This step is critical as it enables the detection of enzyme or receptor activity. A variety of readouts, such as luminescence, fluorescence, or colorimetry, can be employed to measure the activity of the reconstituted enzyme or receptor.
The EFCA technology is an adaptable tool that can be used to measure a wide range of enzyme and receptor activities, including kinase activity, protease activity, GPCR activation, and nuclear receptor activation. The beauty of this technology lies in its ability to detect multiple activities with high accuracy and precision, which is essential for researchers seeking to understand complex biological systems.
Schematic diagram showing the three-dimensional structure of firefly luciferase enzyme with indicated sites used for generating different NH2 and COOH (white) and only COOH (yellow) terminal fragments for the fragment complementation strategy (Paulmurugan et al., 2005).
The technologically advanced EFCA method is a widely accepted and preferred technique for evaluating protein activity as it offers a plethora of advantages over traditional assays. The exceptional sensitivity of EFCA technology stands out as one of the most significant advantages as it enables the detection of protein activity at remarkably low levels that would typically escape detection by other methods. EFCA also presents unparalleled specificity as it heavily relies on the binding of ligands or interacting proteins to the protein of interest, thereby avoiding any nonspecific interactions with other cellular components.
In addition to its sensitivity and specificity, EFCA technology also exhibits remarkable adaptability to diverse assay formats, including high-throughput screening of compound libraries. This adaptable nature facilitates the rapid identification of potential drug candidates, thereby enabling the screening of large numbers of compounds within a relatively short period. Furthermore, the versatility of EFCA technology allows for its seamless integration into automation processes, which boosts its throughput and ultimately leads to a drastic reduction in the time and resources required for drug discovery.
While the EFCA technology offers several advantages over traditional assays, it also has some limitations that should be considered when designing experiments. One limitation is the requirement for the fusion of the protein of interest to the reporter enzyme or receptor fragments, which can alter the protein's native conformation and potentially affect its activity or interaction with ligands or other proteins. Additionally, the presence of the fusion tag may interfere with the binding of small molecules to the protein of interest, limiting the assay's usefulness for drug discovery.
Another limitation of EFCA technology is the potential for false positives or false negatives due to non-specific interactions or assay interference. While the assay's high specificity and sensitivity reduce the risk of false results, researchers should carefully consider the experimental conditions and controls when designing and interpreting EFCA experiments.
The EFCA technology has a wide range of applications in drug discovery, from early target identification to late-stage drug development. One of the most common applications of EFCA technology is high-throughput screening (HTS) of large compound libraries for potential drug candidates. The assay's sensitivity and specificity make it well-suited for the rapid identification of hits and leads from large libraries, which can then be further optimized and tested in subsequent assays and studies.
EFCA technology can also be used for target identification and validation, particularly in cases where the protein of interest has not been well-characterized or is difficult to study using other methods. By measuring the activity of the protein of interest in response to ligands or other proteins, researchers can gain insights into the protein's function and potential therapeutic targets.
β-Lactamase fragment structure and complementation assays in bacteria (Wehrman et al., 2002).
In addition, EFCA technology can be used to profile the selectivity and potency of drug candidates for proteins of interest, thereby identifying compounds with high specificity and minimal off-target effects, which can help reduce the risk of adverse effects and increase the likelihood of successful drug development.