Method |
HITS-CLIP |
PAR-CLIP |
iCLIP / eCLIP |
RIP-seq |
Crosslinking |
UV-C 254 nm |
UV-A 365 nm + 4SU/6SG metabolic labeling |
UV-C 254 nm (enhanced protocols and recovery) |
None (native IP) or mild crosslinking |
Diagnostic Signature |
Crosslink-induced deletions in cDNA |
T→C transitions at crosslink sites |
Truncation/start-site signatures; improved site precision |
No nucleotide-level signature |
Nominal Resolution |
Near-nucleotide (deletion-enriched peaks) |
Single-nucleotide (T→C) in labeling-competent systems |
Single-nucleotide, highest site precision among CLIP variants |
Region-level (enrichment only) |
Sample Compatibility |
Cells & snap-frozen tissues; no labeling required |
Requires nucleoside labeling (best in cultured cells) |
Cells & some tissues; more steps but broadly applicable |
Broad (cells/tissues); simplest logistics |
When It Excels |
In-tissue mapping; projects where labeling is impractical |
Precise site calling with strong T→C signal; high S/N in cell culture |
Projects demanding maximal site precision & recovery |
Rapid target discovery; screening & QC confirmation |
Key Limitations |
Deletion signal weaker than T→C; optimization needed |
Labeling may alter biology; not feasible in many tissues/in vivo |
More complex workflows; higher input/QC burden |
Lower specificity; higher background without crosslinking |
Typical Inputs |
Moderate; tunable by RNase titration |
Moderate; labeling competency required |
Moderate–High; replicate-heavy designs common |
Low–Moderate |
Controls Required |
IgG, input, ± no-UV |
IgG, input; unlabeled controls |
IgG, input, ± no-UV |
IgG, input |
Signature-Aware Peak Calling |
Yes (deletion-aware models) |
Yes (T→C transition models) |
Yes (truncation/start-site aware) |
No (enrichment-only peaks) |
Best For |
Tissue studies; broad applicability without labeling |
Cell-based systems needing crisp single-nucleotide calls |
High-precision mapping; publication-grade site catalogs |
Hypothesis generation; antibody QC; quick target lists |
Caveats to Plan For |
UV dose/footprint tuning; antibody quality |
4SU/6SG uptake, phototoxicity, metabolic effects |
Library complexity & duplication; stringent QC |
Interpret with caution—binding ≠ direct contact |